E3 2015 is over and the dust has settled over what was certainly an impressive showing. The Last Guardian is back, Uncharted 4, Halo 5, Final Fantasy VII, Shenmue 3. It reads like a wish-list rather than an after show discussion, but everyone came out in full force for the show this year…except Nintendo.

But now is not the time to bash Nintendo for their poor show, now is the time of handing out arbitrary awards to games we haven’t played, wooo games journalism. The rules are simple; gameplay has to have been shown of the title. You don’t win game of E3 by showing a CG trailer and calling it a day, sorry Final Fantasy VII remake.

Without any further ado, here are a few of our writers’ picks for the best game of E3 2015.

And the winner is...